TX STATETexas Court of Appeals, 1st District (Houston)
2008

ARCO Construction Company, Inc. v. Americon Services Company, Inc.

Texas Court of Appeals, 1st District (Houston) • Decided 2008Enforced

HOLDING

ARCO, a general contractor, withheld payment to subcontractor Americon unless Americon signed away its right to dispute claims. The Texas court ruled this violated the Prompt Payment Act and awarded Americon $61,417.70 plus interest and attorney's fees. The court also excused Americon's breach of an indemnification clause because ARCO's own violations were so serious. This case protects subcontractors from being forced to choose between getting paid and keeping their legal rights.

KEY FINDINGS

Pay-When-Paid

Never accept a condition that you must waive disputed claims to get paid for undisputed work. This violates Texas law and you can sue for damages.

Lien Waiver

Document everything in writing. Keep records of what work was completed, what was paid, and what remains owed so you can prove which amounts are truly undisputed.

Lien Rights

If a contractor breaches the Prompt Payment Act, you may be excused from performing your own contract obligations, including indemnification duties. Consult an attorney immediately if payment is withheld.

FULL COURT OPINION