Homestar Prop. Solutions, LLC v. Safeguard Props., LLC
358 F. Supp. 3d 807 | District Court, D. Maine | 2019
What This Case Means for Subcontractors
Homestar, a property preservation contractor, sued Safeguard for unpaid work but lost because it violated their contract by filing mechanics' liens in states where lien waivers are enforceable. The court ruled that Homestar breached the lien waiver provision and must pay Safeguard's damages. This case shows that if you sign a contract waiving lien rights, you cannot file liens in states that allow such waivers—doing so is a breach that can cost you money.
Key Takeaways
- •Read lien waiver clauses carefully before signing. They are enforceable in 8 states and unenforceable in 10 states, so the same clause may or may not apply depending on where the work is performed.
- •Filing a lien after signing a lien waiver agreement can trigger a breach of contract claim and force you to indemnify (pay back) the other party for all resulting costs and damages.
- •If you cannot afford to waive lien rights, negotiate the contract before signing. Once signed, filing liens anyway is a costly mistake that courts will enforce against you.
Homestar breached the contract's Lien Waiver Provision when it filed mechanics' liens in lien-waivable states.
Frequently Asked Question
Can I file a mechanics' lien if I signed a lien waiver agreement?
No, not in states that allow lien waivers by contract. If you sign a lien waiver and then file a lien anyway, you breach the contract and must pay the other party's damages. Some states prohibit lien waivers entirely, so check your state's law before signing any agreement that restricts your lien rights.
Related Cases
Gall v. United States
Appellate courts must review all sentences under an abuse-of-discretion standard regardless of whether they fall inside or outside the Guidelines range, and cannot require extraordinary circumstances to justify sentences outside the range.
Piotrowski v. City of Houston
Municipal liability under § 1983 requires proof of official policy as the moving force; isolated employee misconduct insufficient, and equal protection claim time-barred.
Adarand Constructors, Inc. v. Pena
Federal race-based classifications must be analyzed under strict scrutiny regardless of whether they benefit or burden minorities, and the Fifth Amendment's equal protection obligation equals the Fourteenth Amendment's.
Northeastern Florida Chapter of the Associated General Contractors of America v. City of Jacksonville
An association of contractors has standing to challenge a minority set-aside ordinance without proving any member would have won a contract absent the ordinance; the injury is denial of equal competitive opportunity, not loss of a specific contract.
Fitzgerald v. Advanced Spine Fixation Systems, Inc.
A manufacturer must indemnify an innocent seller for products liability litigation costs under Texas Civil Practice & Remedies Code § 82.002(a), even if the seller did not sell the particular defective product that injured the plaintiff, provided the seller qualifies as a 'seller' under the statute.
In Re Kellogg Brown & Root, Inc.
The Civil Commitment of Sexually Violent Predators Act is civil, not criminal, and does not violate due process even when applied to incompetent defendants.