TX STATECourt of Appeals of Texas
2017

Levco Constr., Inc. v. Whole Foods Mkt. Rocky Mountain/Sw. L.P.

549 S.W.3d 618Court of Appeals of Texas • Decided 2017Enforced

HOLDING

Levco, a subcontractor, sued the building owner (Whole Foods) directly for fraud after the general contractor (CCI) failed to pay. The court ruled that Levco could not recover from the owner, even though fraud was proven, because the subcontract's pay-if-paid clause and flow-down provisions limited Levco's claims to its direct contractor only. This means subcontractors cannot bypass their general contractor to sue the owner directly, regardless of fraud.

KEY FINDINGS

Pay-If-Paid

Pay-if-paid clauses block subcontractor claims against owners—you can only sue your direct contractor, not the owner, even if the owner committed fraud

Lien Waiver

Flow-down provisions in subcontracts tie your rights to the general contractor's contract terms; review these carefully before signing

Lien Rights

Fraud findings alone do not override contractual payment limitations—you must pursue claims through your direct contractor first

FULL COURT OPINION