CA STATECalifornia Court of Appeal
2023

Rheinhart v. Nissan North America

California Court of Appeal • Decided 2023Reversed

HOLDING

A California court ruled that a settlement agreement releasing a manufacturer from its legal duty to repurchase or replace a defective vehicle violates the Song-Beverly Act and is void. The court found that consumers cannot waive their statutory rights under this law, even if they voluntarily sign a settlement agreement. For subcontractors, this means settlement agreements that try to eliminate statutory obligations may be unenforceable if they conflict with consumer protection laws.

KEY FINDINGS

Lien Waiver

Never rely on a settlement agreement or release to eliminate statutory duties or consumer protection rights—courts will void them as against public policy.

Lien Rights

If you settle a warranty dispute, ensure the agreement complies with applicable consumer protection statutes or it may be challenged and declared unenforceable.

FULL COURT OPINION