J.H. Lynch & Sons, a subcontractor on a Navy project, sued the general contractor's surety for unpaid work totaling over $575,000. The general contractor had included a pay-when-paid clause in the subcontract, which the surety argued blocked Lynch's claim. The court rejected this argument and ruled that pay-when-paid clauses cannot prevent subcontractors from pursuing Miller Act claims against sureties. This decision protects subcontractors' federal payment bond rights regardless of what their subcontracts say.
Pay-when-paid clauses in your subcontract cannot stop you from suing the payment bond surety under the Miller Act—your federal rights override contract language
If you work on a federal project and don't get paid, pursue the surety directly; don't let the general contractor hide behind contract terms
Document all work completion dates and unpaid invoices carefully, as these are critical to proving your Miller Act claim against the surety
Email any GC contract to contracts@legalmerit.com - you'll get a marked-up redline and risk report in 15 minutes. First 3 free, no card, no signup.
Email a contract →