FEDERALCourt of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
2002

United States For The Use And Benefit Of Walton Technology, Inc. v. Weststar Engineering, Inc.

290 F.3d 1199Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit • Decided 2002Remanded

HOLDING

Walton Technology, a subcontractor, rented equipment to the prime contractor Weststar on a federal construction project but wasn't paid. The contract had a 'pay when and if paid' clause, which Weststar argued meant Walton couldn't sue until the government paid Weststar. The Ninth Circuit ruled that this clause doesn't eliminate a subcontractor's rights under the Miller Act payment bond. Subcontractors can sue the surety for payment even if the prime contractor hasn't been paid by the government.

KEY FINDINGS

Pay-When-Paid

A 'pay when and if paid' clause in your subcontract does not waive your Miller Act rights—you can still sue the payment bond surety directly

Lien Rights

You do not have to wait for the government to pay the prime contractor before filing a Miller Act claim against the surety

Dispute Resolution

Document all work, equipment rental, and delivery carefully to support your Miller Act claim if payment is withheld

FULL COURT OPINION