FEDERALDistrict Court, D. Delaware
2012

In re W.R. Grace & Co.

475 B.R. 34District Court, D. Delaware • Decided 2012Enforced

HOLDING

W.R. Grace & Co., a major chemical and construction materials manufacturer, went through a lengthy Chapter 11 bankruptcy reorganization. The court approved a settlement agreement with insurance companies (CNA) and confirmed the reorganization plan after rejecting all objections. This case is important to subcontractors because Grace was a significant supplier and contractor in the construction industry, and the settlement established how insurance and indemnification obligations would be handled during the company's restructuring.

KEY FINDINGS

Broad Indemnification

Broad indemnification clauses in settlement agreements can survive bankruptcy court scrutiny if properly documented and justified—review your contracts with major suppliers for similar language

Insurance Requirements

Insurance requirements and dispute resolution mechanisms are critical components of bankruptcy settlements; ensure your subcontracts clearly define who carries insurance and how disputes get resolved

Dispute Resolution

When working with companies in financial distress, document all agreements in writing and understand the indemnification chain, as courts will enforce these provisions even in bankruptcy

FULL COURT OPINION